Paying an employee back for something personal used to be simple and expensive: it was cash, so PAYE applied. For benefits on or after 1 April 2026, the 2026 Act lets you choose FBT instead, where the expense would have been an unclassified benefit had you bought it for them (IR409 pp2, 4 and 20; AC2026 pp164 to 165). Business expenses you reimburse are a different matter and are not taxed as income at all.
The choice from April 2026
Before the change, reimbursing a personal expense was a payment of cash to the employee and so PAYE income (IR409 p4). Providing the same thing directly was a non-cash benefit under FBT, with the de minimis limits available. The 2026 Act removed that difference: for benefits provided on or after 1 April 2026, an employer may treat the reimbursement of a personal expense as an unclassified benefit, if the expense would have been an unclassified benefit had the employer provided it directly (IR409 p20; AC2026 pp164 to 165). It is designed so the same item is not taxed twice.
Within the limits: no FBT and no PAYE
Once treated as an unclassified benefit, the reimbursement joins the employee's other unclassified benefits and gift cards for the $300 per employee per quarter ($1,200 a year) and $22,500 all-employee limits (IR409 p24). Below both limits, there is neither FBT nor PAYE. Above either, FBT applies to the whole amount.
Worked example
You reimburse an employee $180 for a personal purchase that would have been an unclassified benefit had you bought it, and choose FBT.
- Value: $180.00, with no employee contribution.
- Per-employee test: $180.00 is not more than $300.00, assuming no other unclassified benefits that quarter.
- All-employee test: within $22,500.
- Taxable value: $0.00.
A $420 reimbursement fails the per-employee test, so the whole $420.00 is taxable: FBT $268.50 at 63.93%, plus GST at 3/23 of the value, $54.78, if you are GST registered (IR409 p50). Compare that with PAYE at the employee's marginal rate before choosing.
When the choice does not apply
- Motor vehicles: reimbursing vehicle running costs is not covered by this choice (AC2026 p164: "this approach will not apply to motor vehicles"). Vehicle benefits follow the motor vehicle rules; see the vehicle guide.
- Accommodation: not covered, and accommodation is a PAYE matter, not FBT (AC2026 p164).
- Business expenses the employee pays on your behalf are not income at all; this rule is about personal expenses.
- Tax-free allowances and non-cash benefits given instead of one are not fringe benefits (IR409 p4).
- Reimbursed expenses do not reduce a vehicle benefit: only contributions the employee bears count (IR409 p17).
For items that are never fringe benefits, read what is not FBT.
How it sits with gift cards
A similar choice already applies to gift cards and vouchers, for benefits from 16 April 2025 (AC2026 p162). Retailer-specific cards are FBT; general-use cards are PAYE unless you choose FBT. Both choices exist for the same reason: to treat equivalent benefits the same way. See gift cards: FBT or PAYE.
Proposed fixes (NOT LAW)
The 2026 FBT simplification bill would have fixed some gaps in this equalisation, backdated to 1 April 2026 (BC2026 p230). That bill lapsed at the dissolution of Parliament for the election; not law (status checked 16 November 2026). Until it is reinstated and passed, apply the rule as enacted in the 2026 Act. Record each reimbursement, the expense, the date and which treatment you chose (IR409 p26), and total your return with the FBT return calculator.
Questions
Is reimbursing an employee subject to PAYE or FBT?
PAYE by default for personal expenses. From 1 April 2026 you can choose FBT instead where the expense would have been an unclassified benefit had you provided it (IR409 p20).
Can I use the choice for fuel or car costs?
No. Motor vehicles are excluded from the choice (AC2026 p164).
Sources
- IR409 Fringe benefit tax guide (April 2026), pp2, 4, 20 and 24
- Act commentary: Taxation (Annual Rates for 2025-26, Compliance Simplification, and Remedial Measures) Act 2026, pp164 to 165
- IRD bill commentary (September 2026, NOT LAW), p230
- IRD: About unclassified benefits and gift cards
Official sources checked 16 November 2026. General information as at that date, not tax advice; rules change, and if anything here differs from Inland Revenue’s guidance, follow IRD. For complex cases ask a tax agent. Spotted an error? Email crucibleinvestmentsltd@gmail.com.