Cost price or tax book value: which costs less?
Cost price is a steady 20% a year of the GST-inclusive cost. Tax book value starts higher, at 36%, but falls as the vehicle depreciates, to a floor of $8,333 (IR409 pp14 to 15).
NOT LAW The proposed 2027 vehicle categories are not law: the bill lapsed when Parliament was dissolved (checked 16 November 2026). Today’s rules apply. Details
The short answer
Example: a $60,000 vehicle with 30% diminishing value depreciation. Over 5 years, cost price gives $60,000.00 of taxable value and tax book value $59,898.96.
Worked example: a vehicle over five years. Change any figure to see your own.
Lower total taxable value: Tax book value
Over 5 years, cost price gives $60,000.00 of taxable value and tax book value gives $59,898.96.
| Year | Tax book value at start | Value used | Cost price × 20% | Tax book value × 36% |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Year 1 | $60,000.00 | $60,000.00 | $12,000.00 | $21,600.00 |
| Year 2 | $42,000.00 | $42,000.00 | $12,000.00 | $15,120.00 |
| Year 3 | $29,400.00 | $29,400.00 | $12,000.00 | $10,584.00 |
| Year 4 | $20,580.00 | $20,580.00 | $12,000.00 | $7,408.80 |
| Year 5 | $14,406.00 | $14,406.00 | $12,000.00 | $5,186.16 |
| Total | $60,000.00 | $59,898.96 |
- Year 1 uses cost price under both methods: tax book value is cost price in the year the vehicle is bought (IR409 p14).
- Tax book value is never taken below the minimum of $8,333 (IR409 p15).
- Our model: diminishing value depreciation at the rate entered, a full year from year 1, no private use adjustment. Your depreciation schedule may differ.
- Whichever you choose stays fixed for 5 years, or until the vehicle is sold or the lease ends (IR409 p14).
Read next: Investment Boost and vehicle FBT · the motor vehicle guide
General information using IRD’s published method as at the date checked, not tax advice. If anything here differs from IR409, ird.govt.nz or myIR, follow Inland Revenue.
Worked example shown. Change any figure to see your own result (needs JavaScript). The address bar keeps your figures, so you can share the link.
The two methods
| Value basis | Quarterly and annual returns (a quarter) | Income year returns |
|---|---|---|
| Cost price, GST-inclusive | 5% | 20% |
| Cost price, GST-exclusive | 5.75% | 23% |
| Tax book value, GST-inclusive | 9% | 36% |
| Tax book value, GST-exclusive | 10.35% | 41.40% |
| Tax book value with Investment Boost, GST-inclusive (from 1 April 2026) | 10.35% | 41.40% |
| Tax book value with Investment Boost, GST-exclusive (from 1 April 2026) | 11.90% | 47.61% |
You choose one per vehicle and keep it until the vehicle is sold, the lease ends or 5 years pass from the first FBT period (IR409 p14).
Why tax book value often wins later
Tax book value falls each year with depreciation, while cost price stays the same. In our example a $60,000 vehicle gives $12,000.00 a year at cost price; at tax book value the first year is $21,600.00 and the fifth $5,186.16. Over five years: $60,000.00 against $59,898.96.
Investment Boost vehicles
From 1 April 2026, if Investment Boost was claimed, tax book value is cost less Investment Boost and depreciation, the percentage rises to 41.40% a year (GST-inclusive) and the minimum is $7,317. The change “effectively ignores the Investment Boost deduction” (IRD Act commentary, p163). Cost price is unaffected (IR409 pp14 to 15).
When this calculator does not apply
- Leased vehicles use the value the lessor gives you; previously leased vehicles may use market value (IR409 p15).
- Car dealers’ pooled trading stock uses the average value (IR409 p15).
- This is a model with your depreciation rate. For one period, use the motor vehicle calculator.
Sources
- IR409 Fringe benefit tax guide (April 2026)
- IRD: Calculating taxable value for private use of vehicles (updated 1 April 2026)
- IRD Act commentary, Taxation (Annual Rates for 2025-26, Compliance Simplification, and Remedial Measures) Act 2026
Official sources checked 16 November 2026. General information as at that date, not tax advice; if anything here differs from Inland Revenue’s guidance, follow IRD.
Questions
Can I change method each year?
No. The method is fixed for 5 years, or until sale or lease end.
More calculators
Other FBT calculators
Quick FBT estimate
One vehicle plus other taxable benefits for a quarter: FBT, GST and the due date.
Open →Motor vehicle FBT calculator
Cost price or tax book value, days, contributions, Investment Boost, pools and GST.
Open →Vehicle days calculator
Liable and exempt days, overnight take-home, call-outs and the 3-month test.
Open →Work-related vehicle checker
The work-related vehicle requirements, one by one, with the days that stay liable.
Open →FBT rate chooser
Single, full alternate, short form or pooled: which costs least for an employee.
Open →FBT alternate rate calculator
The year-end multi-rate calculation, IRD’s columns, to the cent.
Open →Remuneration adjustment calculator
Last year’s 49.25% recalculated on actual income.
Open →Low-interest loan calculator
Daily balances at the prescribed rate (6.07% from 1 October 2026), including rate changes.
Open →Overdrawn current account calculator
Shareholder current accounts in debit, day by day at the prescribed rate.
Open →Gift card and $300 limit checker
Unclassified benefits against both limits, and the whole-amount trap.
Open →Staff discount calculator
Goods and services at a discount, the 5% concession and goods on special.
Open →FBT return calculator
IR420, IR421 and IR422 totals with GST at 3/23 and the due date.
Open →2027 vehicle calculator (NOT LAW)
Today’s FBT beside the lapsed bill’s categories and EV rates.
Open →